Thursday, June 12, 2008

Bang Crunch By Neil Smith








The Art of Short Story




This is Neil Smith’s debut book of 9 short stories. It’s somewhat uneven, like most books of short fiction. Some of the stories were gems and a couple duds.

I especially enjoyed "The B9ers", the story of a support group for people who had benign tumors. Yes, you read write, the non-lethal variety of tumor. This story was both humorous and touching.

Another story I enjoyed was the title story, "Bang Crunch". It’s the touching story about a girl born with Fred Hoyle syndrome. First she ages rapidly and then goes backward, back to an embryo again.

There were only 2 stories that I didn’t care for at all. "Green Fluorescent Protein" and "Extremities". They were just too "out there" for me.

Neil Smith is a strong writer. He writes with sensitivity and wicked humour. Though I didn’t like all the stories in this collection, I highly recommend it. The stories I enjoyed were well worth the time!

3.5/5

Note: If you have also reviewed this book, please feel free to post you link in the comments. I will then add it to the end of my review.

8 comments:

Nymeth said...

Humour and sensitivity is always a good combination. This book sounds interesting. It's too bad it was uneven, but like you said that's often the case with short stories.

Also, I love that cover.

Teddy Rose said...

Nymeth,
I really liked the cover too. Like I said, there were only 2 stories that I really disliked. It's really a worthwhile book to read.

Katknit said...

Terrific review, Teddy, thanks!

Teddy Rose said...

Linda,

I'm glad you enjoyed my review. Thank you.

John Mutford said...

Sounds like there might be some dark humour in there. I'm intrigued.

Teddy Rose said...

John, I think that you would like some of the stories. He does use dark humour.

Linda in Maine said...

Teddy, if you care for Maeve Binchy's style, I'd completely recommend a couple of her books: "This Year It Will Be Different," shorts with a Christmas theme. And "Victoria Line, Central Line" (released in the U.S. as "London Transport") in which all the stories have some connection with the Underground line. I love the way she links the stories with a theme.

Teddy Rose said...

Linda,

I haven't read any Maeve Binchy yet, but I do have her on my TBR.
'Victoria Line, Central Line' sounds interesting to me, so I added it to my TBR. I'm not into Christmas themes, so I'll give the other a pass.

Thanks for the recommendations.

Post a Comment